The reports this week are that Bud Selig, commissioner of Major League Baseball, is revisiting the Pete Rose case. In case you’ve forgotten, Pete Rose was given a lifetime ban from baseball because he gambled on baseball games. Apparently, Selig may be reconsidering the terms of that ban. If he does, Rose may be eligible for the Hall of Fame. I have mixed feelings on both issues.
In regard to the Hall of Fame, Rose’s career numbers are stellar. He is the all-time hit king of major league baseball. He has over 4,200 hits. In addition, he made seventeen all-star appearances over the course of his career. He was a great player who played with hustle and passion. There is no doubt that his career numbers justify him being in Cooperstown.
Furthermore, most people feel that Rose’s transgressions came after his playing career was over. It seems that Rose’s gambling took place during his managing career, and not during his active playing days. In addition, not even the most hard core cynic would suggest that someone with the competitive streak of Rose would ever bet against his own team. Ray Fosse can testify to how much Pete Rose wants to win. Subsequently, many believe that Rose’s post-playing days should be overlooked, and the focus merely be on his active playing career.
On the other hand, there are three major reasons why Rose should not be reinstated and made eligible for the Hall of Fame. First, he bet on baseball. Second, he bet on baseball. Third, he bet on baseball. He committed the unpardonable sin. He gambled on the game. Ask Shoeless Joe Jackson where that gets you. It gets you banned, no matter how great you were. Baseball has a sensitivity towards gambling like no other sport. They experienced first hand how destructive it can be on the game. The Black Sox scandal of 1919 seared the minds of the baseball community. Gambling, and gamblers, cannot be tolerated.
I’m not sure what Commissioner Selig will do, or even what he should do. One day, I feel lenient. The next, hard-core. Let him back in. Keep him out forever. I’m not sure what’s right. I lean towards keeping the ban in place. But, even with that said, I realize that Rose’s future is not an easy decision. I don’t envy Selig. But let’s be clear about one thing. Rose himself, not Selig (or former commissioner Bart Giamatti for that matter), is the one who has kept him out of the Hall of Fame. Rose knowingly broke the rules. He knowingly lied for years about it. He severely damaged his most recent chance at restoration by confessing for a payday in his tell-all book. Pete Rose got himself banned, and has kept himself banned. Bud Selig merely has to determine whether or not to undo the damage Rose has done to himself.